Beyond Shakahola: Is Your Faith a Refuge or a Cage?

On some weekends in Kenya, we gather for joyous occasions—weddings, celebrations, and football matches. Yet, just last year in the Shakahola forest, a different kind of gathering took place: mass burials. The world watched in horror as nearly 457 bodies—fathers, mothers, and children—were unearthed from shallow graves. Their deaths were not from disease or violence, but from a calculated form of coercion, sold to them as a path to heaven. They were victims of a so-called “church” that weaponized their faith, promising salvation through starvation.

“This was not faith; this was fanaticism. This was not worship; this was weaponization,” as the author rightly puts it.

As a psychologist and theologian, I can tell you a hard truth: the danger of extremist movements is not a rare occurrence in Kenya, nor is it over. In a grim and chilling reminder of this, recent weeks have seen investigators uncover new suspected mass graves near the original site. Fresh bodies and human remains have been exhumed from a nearby village, with forensic experts noting that some of the remains appear to be from more recent burials. This ongoing discovery highlights the enduring and hidden nature of this threat.

The Psychology of Vulnerability

No one willingly joins a deadly cult. The journey toward extremism is subtle and gradual. It preys on fundamental human needs that are universal and powerful.

• The Need to Belong: When life feels lonely and hostile, a group that offers unconditional love and a sense of “family” is incredibly compelling.
• The Need for Healing: In the face of chronic illness, poverty, or profound grief, promises of miraculous cures offer a desperate hope where traditional institutions have failed.
• The Need for Purpose: Amidst high unemployment and societal corruption, apocalyptic teachings can give ordinary people a grand, cosmic role in a battle between good and evil.
• The Need for Certainty: In a chaotic world, a leader who claims to have a direct line to God provides an anchor of absolute truth, offering clarity where there is none.

These are not weaknesses. They are deeply human desires for connection, healing, purpose, and stability. But in the wrong hands, they become powerful levers of manipulation. As Dr. Robert Jay Lifton, a renowned psychiatrist and expert on cults, explained, cultic leaders “exploit basic human needs for belonging, meaning, and security to exert absolute control.” This is the psychological foundation of their power.

The Anatomy of Control

Cults do not persuade; they condition. They don’t argue; they rewire. The process involves a systematic breakdown of a follower’s critical thinking and identity.

1. Isolation: Followers are methodically cut off from “worldly” friends and family. The cult becomes the sole source of community and support, creating a dependency that is hard to break. The Rev. Dr. Timothy G. Shambo, a Kenyan theologian, noted, “They are told to leave their families, to sell their property, and to come and live with us. This is the first red flag.”
2. Fear and Guilt: Scripture is twisted to instill a deep-seated fear of hellfire and an overwhelming sense of guilt. Questioning the leader is framed as questioning God, making dissent unthinkable. As one survivor from a different Kenyan cult shared, “We were taught that the world outside was evil, and to question the ‘man of God’ was to invite the devil in.”
3. Milieu Control: The entire environment is engineered—from language and music to dress codes—until the world outside the group feels demonic and threatening.
4. Exploitation of Sacrifice: The more someone gives—their time, money, health, or relationships—the harder it becomes to admit they were deceived. This is the “sunk-cost trap,” and it makes leaving seem like an unbearable loss.
5. Charismatic Authority: Leaders claim to have unique visions, dreams, and divine revelations, using “God told me” as a way to silence all questions and maintain absolute control. “The hallmark of a cult leader is absolute authority and infallibility,” says Dr. A.D. Okal, a Kenyan psychologist. “They present themselves as the only link to God, and everyone else is a distraction.”

By the time followers realize they are trapped, the cost of leaving feels insurmountable. They have already sacrificed their loved ones, their finances, and their health, sometimes even their lives.

The Deception of a False Gospel

Let’s be unequivocally clear: Jesus never demanded starvation as proof of holiness. He never taught that medicine is evil. He never asked for blind loyalty to human leaders. The true Gospel is a message of life, dignity, and freedom. Cults, however, twist this message into a cage. They glorify suffering, disguise control as “faith,” and promise heaven while delivering only graves. As the renowned theologian and author C.S. Lewis wrote, “A man can no more be a Christian by following the leader of his sect than a person can be an artist by only imitating a painter.”

Why Kenya Is Vulnerable

Kenya’s landscape is fertile ground for these destructive movements.

• Desperation: Widespread poverty and unemployment create a deep hunger for hope and a better life, which unregulated groups are quick to exploit. “The rising cost of living and high unemployment have made people desperate for spiritual and financial deliverance,” explained Fredrick Okang’a, a sociologist at the University of Nairobi.
• Oversaturation: With over 40,000 churches—many of them operating with minimal oversight—it’s tragically easy for anyone to claim the title of “prophet” or “bishop.”
• Low Accountability: Despite past tragedies, the regulation of religious organizations remains weak. When institutions fail, people turn to whoever promises a solution, and that voice is often a wolf in a sheep’s clothing. “The lack of a robust legal and regulatory framework has allowed charlatans to thrive,” stated Dr. Jane Mumo, a legal expert on religious freedom.

What We Must Do to Reclaim Faith

The solution isn’t to fear faith; it is to reclaim its true essence.

• Educate: We must teach our communities about the psychological tactics of manipulation. Awareness is our greatest spiritual armor. “We need to empower citizens with the knowledge to discern between genuine faith and manipulation,” said Dr. John L. Mwangi, a clinical psychologist.
• Regulate: We must demand accountability and sensible oversight for religious organizations. Freedom of worship should never mean freedom to exploit.
• Support: We must strengthen our mental health services, educational systems, and social safety nets so that people don’t have to seek salvation in destructive places.
• Discern: Faith leaders must preach a message of freedom, not fear; of dignity, not bondage.

A Call to Wake Up

The recent discovery of more bodies in the Shakahola area is a stark, urgent reminder that the fight against these “wolves in white robes” is far from over. It highlights that the menace is not confined to one incident but is a pervasive, ongoing threat.

“We cannot keep burying the faithful in forests and calling it ‘holiness’,” as the original article’s author so powerfully stated. “We cannot keep mistaking manipulation for miracles. We cannot keep allowing wolves in white robes to slaughter the sheep.”

Faith should be a fire that warms and illuminates, not one that consumes and destroys. The question is no longer whether cults exist among us. The real question is: will we keep pretending not to see?

Beracah Wellness Services At Beracah Wellness, we focus on psychological therapy, workplace wellness, and building healthy cultures — while empowering communities to stay resilient against today’s challenges.